23 Slips of Paper

August 23, 2011

 

***

I didn’t mean to find the stash, but I did.

“I don’t feel like cleaning my room,” she says sullenly, eyeing the piles of dirty Levis, underwear and Izod shirts on the floor.

I look up from her Seventeen magazine, which I’m devouring. Apparently, the “it” cologne for fall has hints of green apple and peony.  How does Seventeen magazine know this stuff?

“It’s chores,” I say. “You have to. You’ll get in trouble.”

“You’ll get in troub-le,” she mimics, pulling a prissy face. “Goody-Goody.”

“Well you will,” I say, embarrassment rising, a fat disc in my throat.

“Chores are stupid. It’s my room anyways–why should Mom even care what it looks like? You know what? I’m not doing it.”

“No, really. You’ll get in trouble.”  Just the thought of disobeying Mama makes my nerves all jangly.

“What are you gonna do about it, Squeaky Clean?  Tidy up for me?”  Suddenly, her green eyes become greener, cat-like. I know I’m in for it. Her eyes always turn feline when she gets a good idea.

She turns and moves the needle on the record player back, re-starting Billy Squier.

“Clean it for me?”  She smiles. “I’ll pay you a buck.” She cocks her head toward the spinning disc on the turntable. “Bet you can do it before he gets to ‘Rock Me Tonight.'”

She’s already paying me a quarter a day to make her bed in the morning, so I shrug and say, “okay.”  She’s right–it will take me 15 minutes tops to clean it, if I really hustle. Plus, for some reason that’s deep and inexplicable, I don’t want her to get into trouble.

“Excellent,” she says, grabbing the Seventeen out of my hands and heading for the living room. “Enjoy!”

I scoop up the dirty clothes first and scan the room as I walk to the laundry hamper. Her desk is a mess, which doesn’t make sense; the girl rarely does homework.

Returning from the hamper, I pick up dirty tissues, half-eaten Tangy Taffy’s and, using my thumbnail, attempt to scrape plum-colored nail polish off the white surface of the desk. It doesn’t go well. Mama is going to have a fit.

I pick up a treasure–a watermelon Bonnie Bell Lip Smacker–and open the desk drawer to put it in a safe haven. It’s then that I see it. The stash.

A stack of crisp–impossibly crisp–green bills. Twenties, all of them. It’s a big stack. I don’t even have to pick it up to see that there’s a lot of money there.

The room’s suddenly stifling and I think I’m going to throw up. I know what I’m looking at. I want to shut the desk drawer but I can’t quit staring at the green stack.

What I’m looking at is dishonesty.  I don’t have concrete proof but I know it, sure as I’m standing. There’s no way my sister has that kind of money.

But Daddy does. His gas station does. The gas station she resentfully works at on summer days, cursing the red polyester  smock she has to wear.

She hates everything about working at Daddy’s station, except for the free nachos and the paycheck, which comes every second Friday.  The paycheck she immediately blows on concert tickets at Red Rocks, 15 minutes from our house. Two, three times a week, she’s sneaking schnapps into a flask, grabbing her Ray-Bans, spending hours with  Tom Petty and the Heartbreakers, Jimmy Buffet, Loverboy.

She lives for nights on The Rocks.  So much so that I know she hasn’t saved a dime this summer.

Billy’s already on “Rock me Tonight.”  I shut the drawer quickly and look over my shoulder, feeling tarnished. Nobody’s there.

Hurriedly, I tidy up the rest of her room and retreat to mine, shutting the door behind me. I pick up Stephen King’s Salem’s Lot, attempt to get lost in the world of vampires, but my mind won’t stop running.

Dammit. Dammit, dammit, dammit. Stupid idiot, opening drawers. Now you’ve done it. What the Hell are you going to do now? What are you going to do?

***

I last two days. That’s all I can bear. My constitution is weak. I have no endurance for this stuff and I can’t sleep. I tangle and churn in the sheets, weighing which is stronger: sense of justice or fear of my sister’s wrath?

I get out of bed before dawn and sneak into Mama’s room. I crawl in next to her, hummingbird-hearted, and whisper suspicions in her ear.

By the time the sky turns pink, Mama’s taken this out of my hands, and I’m limp with relief. She’ll tell Daddy. They’ll look. They’ll decide what to do. Mama will take the blame for finding the goods. My sister never has to know it was me, that I’m a rat and a tattletale and a snake. A snake who tells on her sister.

“You did the right thing,” Mama whispers, brushing hair off my face, but I’m not so sure.  I’ve broken the most sacred rule of sisterhood: Don’t Tell Your Sister’s Secrets.  Even if Mama’s right, even if it’s the honest thing to do, there’s a sourness in my gut that tells me–“you’ll pay for this.”

***

I try to be out of the house the next few days, avoiding the fallout.  If I’m not in my room, I can’t hear my sister’s indignant denials, the slamming of her bedroom door, the low conversation between my parents. Out of the house is good.

***

I come in from outside and the house is quiet.  I creep upstairs and shut my bedroom door, hand on the doorjamb to muffle the sound.  I slide off my sandals, get on my bed and open Salem’s Lot. When I open to my dog-eared place, there’s a strip of yellow paper in there. In my sister’s loopy script reads: I Hate You.

SheknowsSheknowsSheknowsohshitI’mdeadSheknows.

With a shaking hand, I lift the scrap of paper. I Hate You. Of course she does. I kind of hate me, too. Of course she knows. I’m weak. She can sniff out my guilt like those truffle-hunting pigs. Of course. What on Earth made me think that she would never know?

I spend the next few days hiding from her. And discovering. I open my jewelry box to put on my favorite Swatch watch and am greeted with a yellow slice of paper. I Hate You.

I reach in a drawer for a pair of socks and see yellow. I Hate You.

Nestled in the bristles of my hairbrush: I Hate You.

I don’t throw out the slips of yellow, and I don’t know why.  I keep them in my underwear drawer, and as days go by, the pile gets higher.  My room is a garden of unhappy discoveries, little daggers that remind me I’m a snake.  I’ll think I’ve found them all and then one sneaks up on me, sucker-punch.

Even a month later, I’m still finding the occasional yellow slip.  One month, 23 slips of paper. I keep the yellow shards of paper in my underwear drawer for two more months, unsure that I’ve found them all.

A few days before Halloween, I stuff the notes in a King Soopers grocery bag and sneak them into the garbage can.

I don’t tell anyone, not even Mama.

It’s a secret between sisters.

{ 58 comments… read them below or add one }

Frelle August 23, 2011 at 4:58 am

Oh girl. What a horrible situation to be in. The betrayal that cost you so much.. it was the right thing to do.. but knowing that you would pay for it, and then have to be reminded so often, so concretely, that you had broken her trust. I’m so sorry for that young girl you were, making that decision, and then enduring her hatefulness afterward. *HUG*

Reply

Abby August 23, 2011 at 4:59 am

Wow.
The detail of this memory from so many years ago is incredible, which goes to show how much of an impact it had on you not only at the time, but still today. It’s so vivid, and although I know it was painful to recount, I love the way you built it up and added in all the little things that made it so intoxicating to read. I couldn’t tear myself away.

Plus, I was an only child, so I never had that guilt. I just did all the crap myself and hoped no one ever found out ;) Kidding…kind of.

Reply

Wendi @ Bon Appetit Hon August 23, 2011 at 5:27 am

I hope that saying these words out loud frees you from all the pain and hurt of them. You are one of the bravest people I’ll probably ever meet and I love you more than my luggage.

Reply

Salad in a Jar August 23, 2011 at 5:45 am

Your mom. She must have anguished greatly over your sister. Just reading about it makes me feel pain for your parents….and for you. Got stuck on the phrase, “whispered suspicions into her ear.”. Also, “churning in the sheets.”. How often I have done the latter!

Reply

Evenshine August 23, 2011 at 6:14 am

You did the right thing. x23.
Hope you no longer carry this.
Sending 23 hugs your way.

Reply

Erin Margolin August 23, 2011 at 6:29 am

This was a touching—and hard to read—piece. So vivid with imagery & details. I never had a sister, but always wanted one. Maybe it’s better I didn’t have one. I’d have taken the higher road, like you did.

And I’m sending 46 love notes your way—twice the amount of hateful notes she left for you.

Lovely post, Dana!
xoxoxo

Reply

TKW August 23, 2011 at 6:54 am

Erin,

46 love notes? I’ll keep them all. xo

Reply

Jennifer August 23, 2011 at 6:45 am

The right thing to do is often the hardest. Which sucks. Why can’t the right thing be the easy thing? The thing that doesn’t hurt? That doesn’t make our stomachs churn? I hate that she made you feel bad when you were in the right.

RE your Facebook status, I really hoping writing these memories down sets them free. If not then when what is the point? At least that is what I ask myself sometimes.

Reply

Sherri August 23, 2011 at 7:06 am

You have SUCH a knack for detail – like these memories are truly happening as we read. The little things you say just take me right back to that time too… my favorite was always the Sugar Plum Bonnie Bell Lip Smacker :-).

Reply

TKW August 23, 2011 at 8:49 am

Sherri,

They made Sugar Plum? Now I feel completely cheated.

Reply

HonestConvoGal August 23, 2011 at 7:50 am

This was great. The details made it. I can feel the weight of the guilt of your decision. I hope writing it down set you free. I agree with everyone else. It was the right choice. I do hope your sister has forgiven you.

Reply

Cheryl @ Mommypants August 23, 2011 at 8:20 am

It is so complicated, the relationship between sisters. Of course you did the right thing, but the cost of it. Oh, the cost.

I remember when I was maybe 12 or 13 and was snooping in my sister’s drawer and found a box of condoms – and some were missing. It rocked my world. I didn’t tell, but I remember having that secret and feeling all weird about it.

I am always amazed by your ability to remember the smallest details. It is such a gift.

Reply

Lanita August 23, 2011 at 8:48 am

I know the fear of opening a drawer and having your whole world shaken, dreading what you’ll find. It’s a feeling that doesn’t go away very easily or very quickly.

You are an amazing writer.

Reply

Heather @girlichef August 23, 2011 at 9:25 am

Will you please write a book already? I just devour your words..I can’t get enough!

Reply

Anastasia August 23, 2011 at 10:11 am

Fabulous writing. I would have told, or taken some of the money. :)

Reply

Jenna August 23, 2011 at 10:12 am

You just gave me the shivers.

Reply

LJRich August 23, 2011 at 10:15 am

Yikes. Difficult situation. Also, flashbacks to my own upbringing.

You grew up in a state very close to the state I grew up in. Heh, Red Rocks. Billy Squier, the “Rock Me Tonight” video pretty much ended his career.

Excellent story, as always!

Reply

TKW August 23, 2011 at 11:02 am

LJ,

I know! That video is hysterically hideous. *cringe*

Reply

Maggie S August 23, 2011 at 10:21 am

WOW!!! Isn’t it funny how we call right, “wrong” and wrong, “right”. How precious and that you sacrificed yourself and endured the pain to protect your sister from going further down a terrible road. How tender, that you loved her when she was hating you.

Reply

Kate August 23, 2011 at 10:46 am

23 slips. Wow.

My husband would scoff at her inability to hide the evidence. If you’re going to do wrong, then do it right. (though, thankfully, he prefers to do right to begin with)

Reply

TKW August 23, 2011 at 11:11 am

Kate,

True. She did show a stunning lack of ingenuity.

Reply

Debbie August 23, 2011 at 11:18 am

Justice is not always liberating. Often it is stifling and painful as yours was and continues to be. I hope the passing of time has seen a new (different) mellowed relationship with your sister.

Reply

Katybeth August 23, 2011 at 1:08 pm

I can’t help but wondering what you would want your girls to do? Would you do the same thing again? If you hadn’t told what do you think would have happened? Like Kate (above) I wonder why she left the money so visible….could your sister have wanted someone to find it. As an only raising an only the dynamic between sibs is intriguing.

Reply

Rudri Bhatt Patel @ Being Rudri August 23, 2011 at 2:15 pm

You weave place and people together well. Brilliant title and writing.
Has your sister forgiven you? Have you forgiven yourself? I echo Mama. You did the right thing.

Reply

TKW August 23, 2011 at 4:01 pm

Rudri,

No, and no. But thank you.

Reply

Eva August 23, 2011 at 2:59 pm

I was “that” sister too, at one time. I told on my brother though…. he’s still messed up. 60 years old and I still feel the need to tell on him sometimes, there’s no one to tell though, so I churn up the sheets.

Reply

Mary Lee August 23, 2011 at 3:44 pm

You were a wise child! If you weren’t sure that what you did was the right thing then, surely have two girls has shown you what a mature decision you made.

I do love your stories and the little glimpses into what makes you tick.

Reply

bryan August 23, 2011 at 4:44 pm

Another touching view of your life woven together so well my friend. It is always such a struggle when the right thing feels so wrong. In the end you were doing your best to help your sister but it must have been heart wrenching at the time.

Reply

Elaine August 23, 2011 at 6:16 pm

First off, your images are great here. The crisp dollar bills, the churning in the sheets and the term “hummingbird-hearted” is GOLDEN!! :)

I think she deserved it. But then she was a teenager and they do bad and stupid things. I’m glad you did the right thing and I’m curious to know how she’s feels about this situation today…

And although terribly mean, those slips of paper were pretty ingenious. I’m sorry that she treated you that way though… xo

Reply

TKW August 24, 2011 at 5:31 am

Elaine,

That’s what I thought, too. What cruel and brilliant way to torture someone.

Reply

Contemporary Troubadour August 23, 2011 at 6:24 pm

My heart turned over while I was reading this. Sisterhood is hard when you share the same roof; the aftermath when you go your separate ways sometimes feels harder. All the what ifs. The second guesses. It’s just brutal.

{{{{TKW}}}}

Reply

Cathy August 23, 2011 at 7:28 pm

Oh – there is the rule of sisters and keeping secrets – I have a sister and she’s kept all but one of mine and I’ve kept hers. The one she violated me on though, as an adult I can see why. An inappropriate (by huge proportions) move by the neighbor boy resulting in the extinction of neighborly relations. Well, yeah, she had to tell on that one.

I’ve read these stories about your and your sis – it’s such a bummer that you two aren’t close.

Reply

Linda at Bar Mitzvahzilla August 23, 2011 at 7:38 pm

TKW, those creepy notes put even my own (one) very troubled sister to shame. It’s so hard to be the younger one and to feel that kind of hatred, not to mention the absolute planning and execution it took for her to plant those notes in your room.

You did the right thing. A sister who eventually grew into maturity and awareness and a normalized adult relationship with you would, perhaps, acknowledge this.

Reply

Phoo-d August 23, 2011 at 8:20 pm

Big hugs and love. Sometimes people are just born rotten. It is so painful when they are family and you can’t easily avoid the nastiness they send out into the world.

Reply

Privilege of Parenting August 23, 2011 at 8:33 pm

I could be wrong, but I think she wanted to be caught… she set you up because your dad was too kind to see the clues when the cash was light in the register. She could have hid the money much better, but she was over-paying you to clean, drawing you into her feeling of being “overpaid” at the gas station. And, just maybe, she was looking to you, the honest one, for a clue about how to behave in the face of a dishonesty that left her feeling bad (oppositionality and defiance can be a sign of depression, particularly in adolescents).

From your other writings we know that your sister is a bit of a tragic character; like Able and Also Aaron in “East of Eden,” sometimes it’s hard to be the sibling who finds favor… even if that’s not what you were wanting, but rather your sister’s love.

All those 23 slips are, in their own twisted way, love notes.

Reply

TKW August 24, 2011 at 5:33 am

Ah, Bruce,

My optimist friend. You see good in everyone. It’s lovely.

Reply

elizabeth August 24, 2011 at 7:28 am

Whenever I read these glimpses into your childhood, I know we would have been friends–one of the downsides of being born when I was is that most of my friends were older/the oldest sibling, and didn’t understand the sometimes-unbearable existence that is being the youngest.

Reply

SuziCate August 24, 2011 at 7:32 am

I think most of us with siblings have had that moment of doing what was right or keeping quiet. I was like you. My sons however always held to that brotherly bond of never ratting on one another. I don’t know if that is a male trait or if they were just closer than I was with my sisters. As always this was a touching essay…you made me think mostly about my older two sisters where this situation did play out often.

Reply

Kim at Let Me Start By Saying August 24, 2011 at 7:50 am

Oh, this crushed me. Siblings know each other so well, and can use that information for good or bad. Those yellow notes, that you saved them? What you didn’t tell your parents? This screamed of hope to me. Am I wrong? Like, if you keep them will they add up to a We’re Even Now balance, and all will be okay again?

Reply

TKW August 24, 2011 at 8:01 am

Kim,

Maybe you are right. In all honesty, I don’t know exactly why I saved them, but what you say makes sense.

Reply

Tiffany August 24, 2011 at 8:58 am

I would have done the same thing and would have felt just as bad.

Reply

Amber August 24, 2011 at 9:06 am

I have been there, it’s probably the reason my sister and I still have a so/so relationship. I am not sure why she wanted to tell me secrets anyway, knowing that I’d divulge anything I felt my parents would want me to share. Goody-goody, Molly Mormon, believe me, I’ve heard it all. So reading this? My heart breaks. Breaks because I remember a thousand such memories in which I told my sister’s secrets. I had to, they were eating me up inside.

Reply

Gale @ Ten Dollar Thoughts August 24, 2011 at 9:51 am

It’s not very big of me, but with every post about your sister my desire to punch her grows deeper, as does my desire to hug you.

On the flip side, it makes me feel better about the kind of big sister I was…

Reply

Kiyah August 24, 2011 at 11:02 am

I’ve been meaning to respond to this for days. But I can’t stop reading, and rereading the post.

Like other commenters I don’t have a sister, but always wanted one when I was younger. My adult self is thrilled with the two fabulous brothers I have; and given the wrath with which some of my friends treated me in junior high can’t image what it might have been like with someone who couldn’t choose me as a living companion.

I wonder if you talk about this now with your sister- how each of you remember the event are and how she feels about her behavior. My hope for you is that she’s forgiven you, and that you can laugh about it over a cup of coffee as the kids run wild in the back yard. Because that’s a much nicer memory for me of sisterhood.

Reply

Not a Perfect Mom August 24, 2011 at 6:38 pm

wow…that was fantastic…
I have two sisters and know the feeling…ugh..
you are truly a wonderful writer…

Reply

Heather August 24, 2011 at 8:06 pm

Your stories involving your sister always make me sad. I suspect I always took the relationship I had with my sister for granted. I was certain everyone had that. I’m sorry that you did not. hugs.

Reply

pamela August 24, 2011 at 8:21 pm

Girly, I hope you are writing a book. You write like a prize fighter. This one got me in the gut.

Reply

Nancy C August 25, 2011 at 3:56 am

So incredibly heartbreaking and so, so good. It reads like a novel. I wish, for your sake, that it was. That hummingbird warmth is an incredible image.

Your rocky garden is still bearing quite the harvest, my friend.

Reply

noela August 25, 2011 at 4:31 am

Waaah! what happen? The way you deliver your story is quite remarkable..I was hook from the start and wanted to know what happen next..I just hope everything is now well between you two..

Reply

Maria August 25, 2011 at 4:01 pm

I am so sorry.

I am so sorry that your sister made you do things you didn’t want to do out of fear and obligation.

I am so sorry that your sister lashed out of you in the hardest, most cruel ways.

I am so sorry that you had 23 cruel slips reminding you of something that made you so sad.

Most of all, I am so sorry that she didn’t see you for all your graciousness, caring and devotion.

In the end, I am sorry she missed out on you.

((you))

Reply

Dawn August 25, 2011 at 6:40 pm

Reading this and thinking about my own childhood with one sister and two brothers…I don’t think we ever had anything so remarkably intense between us. I think we were unappreciative of the fact we had siblings and just wanted our own space. On the other hand we’re pretty close now.

Those days must have been terrible for you. And I get that maybe things are not so great between you even now. I hope you can someday overcome those feelings because it’s really really nice to have a sibling who will support you and watch your back when you’re all grown up.

Meanwhile…your writing is fantastic. I echo the comment that I hope you write a book! Just fill it with these essays and we’d all be thrilled!

Reply

Justine August 26, 2011 at 8:57 am

I can’t think of a better way to spend my quiet Friday morning reading your words. They give me goosebumps, you’re so crazy good. I’ve missed you!

Reply

faemom August 29, 2011 at 12:01 am

The difference between boys and girls is girls are genius at payback, boys use their fists. My brothers and I went at it like cats and dogs, but at least it was over after the last punch.

Reply

BigLittleWolf August 29, 2011 at 6:25 am

What a stunning piece of writing, Kitch.

There’s something particularly painful about a sibling relationship that doesn’t work. It’s a hole that can never be filled.

Reply

Jane August 29, 2011 at 6:29 pm

I heart you, Kitch. Hugs to you, dear friend. And your sweet little self did exactly the right thing.

Reply

Kelly September 1, 2011 at 7:02 am

Oh lady. I know this so well. The hurt, the anger, the fear, the grief, the sister who is your deepest, darkest enemy though your whole heart wants to be her closest friend.

Reply

backlink analyzer software July 9, 2012 at 6:31 am

Pretty nice post. I just stumbled upon your weblog and wished to say that I have truly enjoyed surfing around your blog posts. After all I will be subscribing to your rss feed and I am hoping you write again soon!

Reply

movies 2012 July 9, 2012 at 2:27 pm

I just couldn’t leave your website before suggesting that I actually loved the standard info an individual provide in your visitors? Is going to be back ceaselessly to inspect new posts

Reply

Leave a Comment

Previous post:

Next post: